Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

:iconsilenced-echo:
Oh I so agree with *Shacchan! It's a lovely piece!

What I like best is that the fixed form constraint almost doesn't show at all, except for the *rejet* for the sake of the rhyme "The distance is in her hands pressed/Tight and steady in candid prayer". I think this makes the sentence structure sound more French than English...

I love the delicate balance between repetition and variation! :) Apart from the immediately visible parts, there is for instance "With her wild curls and her voice mild" where you resisted the temptation of internal rhyme, which would have thrown off the equilibrium with the end rhyme "wide".

The progression in meaning is also well paved, cumulating with "Now that she is your truth", which makes more sense when we take into account the previous stanzas. I like how you made the other character only half present and almost passive : it can have the very optimistic reading you mentioned, silent adoration, but also a darker interpretation. If she is easier, then could it be cowardice that keeps the protagonist from uttering a word? She speaks a lot, and insisting on a same declaration "the truth is easier" seems to try to convince her lover and herself as well. If she speaks enough or louder than their protests, will it become true?

Truly poetic in that sense :) Keep writing 'thisa !!!!!!!! :D
The Artist thought this was FAIR
3 out of 3 deviants thought this was fair.

Comments


:iconarthisa:
Arthisa Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013  Hobbyist Writer
Thank you for the great critique! =)

Oh, I agree in that line: "The distance is in her hands pressed/Tight and steady in candid prayer". That whole sentence sounded a bit grammatically awkward to me (more than usual for poetry, I mean), but I didn't want to add punctuation between "hands" and "pressed" and no matter how much I thought I couldn't come up with a better way to put it.
(Also, I don't think I ever noticed how short eight syllables really was!)

I'm glad you like the repetition! I wanted to have internal rhyme, which is why I used "wild curls", but no credit to me for any smart balancing equilibrium, I didn't think about how it went with "wide" at all. I think I just wanted to have some difference between the curls and the voice, to bring more attention to the mild voice...

I love your interpretation of the piece! It's exactly what I meant, the quiet cowardice of the you and the stubbornness of the her who is trying to convince both herself and the you... except you made it sound like a darker, worse thing than I thought somehow... =D
Reply
:iconsilenced-echo:
silenced-echo Featured By Owner Jan 22, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Meh, that's to blame on my instinctive gloomy outlook on people ^^;
Reply
:icontiefug:
Tiefug Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013
I totally agree with all that ^^ I especially liked all the *rejet*; not only for the rhyme but it adds meaning because some lines give an idea on their own but then take another meaning when read with the next one, like:

Blood nails and lips that cannot hide
On her skin, nor on yours – protest
Dies in your throat and you shiver.

It's almost as if she's saying "lips that cannot [...] hide protest" but then we see that it links with the next line...

Also, good job with punctuation! ^^ It is too often forgotten... (*pet peeve* =-=)
Reply
:iconumbreonoctie:
UmbreoNoctie Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013  Student General Artist
(Yep I would like to heard it in French, because it's a beautiful work)
Reply
:iconumbreonoctie:
UmbreoNoctie Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013  Student General Artist
Et si tu me la faisais en français maintenon ? :D
Reply
:iconsilenced-echo:
silenced-echo Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Loooool, tu veux dire le poème, non? La poétesse est francophone aussi, je lui laisse la traduction ^^ Sinon je veux bien traduire la critique ;P
Reply
:iconumbreonoctie:
UmbreoNoctie Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013  Student General Artist
owiiii
Reply
Add a Comment: